November 2003
- Fwd: Web vs. Java client Eric Merritt
- Fwd: Web vs. Java client Mike Shaver
- MUD-Dev Digest, Vol 6, Issue 3 Alex Chacha
- MUD-Dev Digest, Vol 6, Issue 3 Zach Collins {Siege}
- java clients (was: MUD-Dev Digest, Vol 6, Issue 3) ceo
- MUD-Dev conference 2003/2004 Brian 'Psychochild' Green
- Biz: Game support Peter Tyson
- Biz: Game support Damion Schubert
- Biz: Game support Daniel.Harman@barclayscapital.com
- Biz: Game support Michael Sellers
- Biz: Game support John Erskine
- Advantage for outside skills T. Alexander Popiel
- Advantage for outside skills Jeff Fuller
- Advantage for outside skills Paul Schwanz
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment szii@sziisoft.com
- Removing access to entertainment Patrick Dughi
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Sheela Caur'Lir
- Removing access to entertainment Marian Griffith
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Paul Schwanz
- Removing access to entertainment Hans-Henrik Staerfeldt
- Removing access to entertainment apollyon .
- Removing access to entertainment Amanda Walker
- Removing access to entertainment Peter Keeler
- Removing access to entertainment Matt Mihaly
- Removing access to entertainment Amanda Walker
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
Shannon writes:
> On Fri 14 Nov, John Buehler wrote:
>> This is an observation about some graphical games that I've
>> played through the years, and a pet peeve that has been building
>> all that while. I don't know if text games have this manifested
>> in any way, but the graphical games sure do: they remove my
>> access to entertainment as part of the normal operation of the
>> game.
>> Example 1: Nighttime and rainstorms.
>> Example 2: Mesmerization.
>> Example 3: Blindness.
>> Example 4: Slow travel in large worlds.
> Honestly, I have to agree with the general point that John is trying
> to make here. As others have stated, games are about fairly and
> equitably overcoming a challenge. The above points can
> essentially be summed up as a collection of elements that prevent
> one from fairly and equitably overcoming a challenge.
While I appreciate the agreement, this really isn't about fairness.
It is more fundamental that that.
You make two statements about mesmerization:
"It is distinctly and decidedly unfun."
"Having been on both ends of this scenario, the bottom line is that
it denies both sides the opportunity to fairly and equitably
overcome a challenge."
The second statement may follow from the first, but it isn't the
point I'm trying to make. I think that the first statement is the
essential truth here, and what I infer from that is that it is
"unfun" because it removes access to the very form of entertainment
that the game is predicated on. It's not about fairness. It's
about just not being able to get to the game's mainstream
entertainment: operating a character to do stuff. A player can't
even operate a character if it becomes mesmerized or stunned. It is
inoperable if it is sitting on a boat, waiting for a destination to
arrive. It's another kind of stun. It is diminished in operation
if the player can't make the decision about where to go (can't see).
Imagine a game based on buying and selling securities. People are
working up strategies and schemes for making money, manipulating the
market, whatever they're up for. Every now and again, there is a
problem with the market and nobody can do any trading. This mimicks
reality, but it removes the very form of entertainment that the game
is predicated on.
Some here will theorize that this equipment failure is simply
another form of entertainment (frustration and anticipation). I say
that it is not entertaining for those who want to play that game.
Simply because players are reacting emotionally to the operations
within the game does not make those operations worthy entertainment.
Game designers are welcome to continue putting in these denial of
service features, but I think that they are ill-conceived attempts
at entertainment and that a game that lacks any such features will
do better than one which retains them.
JB - Removing access to entertainment Daniel.Harman@barclayscapital.com
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Michael "Flury" Chui
- Removing access to entertainment Paul Schwanz
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Sheela Caur'Lir
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Sheela Caur'Lir
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Sheela Caur'Lir
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Daniel.Harman@barclayscapital.com
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Sheela Caur'Lir
- Removing access to entertainment Jeff Crane
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Paul Schwanz
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Chanur Silvarian
- Removing access to entertainment Sheela Caur'Lir
- Removing access to entertainment Michael Sellers
- Removing access to entertainment Amanda Walker
- Removing access to entertainment Matt Mihaly
- Removing access to entertainment Kwon J. Ekstrom
- Removing access to entertainment Brian Lindahl
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Damion Schubert
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Marian Griffith
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Marian Griffith
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Corpheous Andrakin
- Removing access to entertainment Darren Hall
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Sheela Caur'Lir
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Removing access to entertainment Chanur Silvarian
- Removing access to entertainment Amanda Walker
- Removing access to entertainment Jeremy Neal Kelly
- Removing access to entertainment Corpheous Andrakin
- Removing access to entertainment John Buehler
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creations Mike Shaver
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Christer Enfors XW {TN/PAC}
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Lee Sheldon
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Christer Enfors XW {TN/PAC}
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Jeff Thompson
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creations Corey Crawford
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Corpheous Andrakin
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Ren Reynolds
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Daniel.Harman@barclayscapital.com
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Crosbie Fitch
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Amanda Walker
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Ren Reynolds
- Second Life's customers own the IP of their creatio ns Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Effects of skill-imbalances? Joshua Judson Rosen
- download-barriers Joshua Judson Rosen
- download-barriers Matt Mihaly
- Language and platform for Text MUD server =?koi8-r?Q?=22?=Andrew Batyuck=?koi8-r?Q?=22=20?=< javaman@mail.ru>
- Language and platform for Text MUD server Miroslav Silovic
- Language and platform for Text MUD server Kwon J. Ekstrom
- Language and platform for Text MUD server Patrick Dughi
- Language and platform for Text MUD server Alex Chacha
- Ragnarok Wisdom Michael Tresca
- Java on Linux gbtmud
- Java on Linux Artur Biesiadowski
- AS TECHNOLOGY SCATTERS VIEWERS, NETWORKS GO LOOKING FOR THEM Michael Tresca
- Breakdown of Java users Christopher Kohnert
- Second Life's customers get [copyright?] of their creations Joshua Judson Rosen
- Rubies of Eventide shutting down Mantees de Tara
- Rubies of Eventide shutting down Zach Collins {Siege}
- Rubies of Eventide shutting down Sheela Caur'Lir
- Rubies of Eventide shutting down Michael Sellers
- Rubies of Eventide shutting down Koster, Raph
- Dopamine and addiction Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Dopamine and addiction David Love
- Dopamine and addiction a t y mcguire
- Dopamine and addiction Lars Duening
- Dopamine and addiction Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Dopamine and addiction Rayzam
- Dopamine and addiction Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Dopamine and addiction Rayzam
- Dopamine and addiction Marian Griffith
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Eli Stevens
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Jessica Mulligan
- Trusting the client, encrypting data ceo
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Amanda Walker
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Mike Shaver
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Sean Middleditch
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Peter Harkins
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Amanda Walker
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Crosbie Fitch
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Richard A. Bartle
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Mike Shaver
- Trusting the client, encrypting data ceo
- Trusting the client, encrypting data J C Lawrence
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Sean Middleditch
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Mike Shaver
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Paul Schwanz
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Vincent Archer
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Felix A. Croes
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Sean Middleditch
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Alain Hamel
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Richard A. Bartle
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Alex Chacha
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Amanda Walker
- Trusting the client, encrypting data Crosbie Fitch
- Payment Transaction Processing altug
- Payment Transaction Processing Sean Middleditch
- Payment Transaction Processing Jason Smith
- Payment Transaction Processing stanza
- Payment Transaction Processing Matt Mihaly
- Payment Transaction Processing Gary Cooper
- Payment Transaction Processing J C Lawrence
- Payment Transaction Processing Gary Whitten