April 2000
- [Open_Gaming_Moderated] Simplified License for Comment and Critique (fwd) J C Lawrence
- An introduction Brian Green
- An idea for breaking away from the HP/Mana mindset Eli Stevens
- An idea for breaking away from the HP/Mana mindset Ryan P.
- An idea for breaking away from the HP/Mana mindset Erik Jarvi
- An idea for breaking away from the HP/Mana mindset Eli Stevens
- An idea for breaking away from the HP/Mana mindset Travis Casey
- An idea for breaking away from the HP/Mana mindset Jeremy Hovance
- An idea for breaking away from the HP/Mana mindset adam@treyarch.com
- Old Topic: Playfulness in 3-D Spaces, done. Rudy Fink
- META: Topic List - 1999 Jon A. Lambert
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Jon A. Lambert
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! cg@ami-cg.GraySage.Edmonton.AB.CA
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Cynbe ru Taren
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Miroslav Silovic
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Jay Carlson
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Travis Casey
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Derek Snider
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Holly Sommer
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Nick Shaffner
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Travis S. Casey
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Quzah
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Todd McKimmey
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Spin
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Richard Woolcock
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Hans-Henrik Staerfeldt
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Miroslav Silovic
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Jon A. Lambert
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Jon Leonard
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Travis Casey
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Powell, Warren
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Travis Casey
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Jon Lambert
- Fw: 16K mud server competition ! Travis Casey
- Fw: DESIGN: XML? Jon A. Lambert
- PK / anti PK / justice? J. Coleman
- Neverwinter Nights Jeff Freeman
- J (was: 16K mud server competition !) Cynbe ru Taren
- J (was: 16K mud server competition !) Miroslav Silovic
- J (was: 16K mud server competition !) Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Morality and Values Based Role Play in MMORPGs. Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- MUD-Dev request rejected (fwd) Matthew Mihaly
- MUD-Dev request rejected (fwd) adam@treyarch.com
- MUD-Dev request rejected (fwd) Jeff Freeman
- Orthogonality and invariants Miroslav Silovic
- Orthogonality and invariants cg@ami-cg.GraySage.Edmonton.AB.CA
- Uptime numbers (was Orthogonality and invariants) Jay Carlson
- Schmuse J C Lawrence
- Article on WoC's 'Open Sourcing' D&D in Salon Christopher Allen
- Multilevel server concept Draymoor
- Multilevel server concept Tochiro
- Multilevel server concept Emil Eifrem
- Multilevel server concept Kristen L. Koster
- Multilevel server concept Brian Green
- Multilevel server concept Hans-Henrik Staerfeldt
- Polls at Kanga.Nu claw@kanga.nu
- Same-Sex Marriage (was: Trouble Makers or Regular Citizens) Ananda Dawnsinger
- Same-Sex Marriage (was: Trouble Makers or Regular Citizens) David Bennett
- Same-Sex Marriage (was: Trouble Makers or Regular Citizens) Matthew Mihaly
- Same-Sex Marriage (was: Trouble Makers or Regular Citizens) Ananda Dawnsinger
- Same-Sex Marriage (was: Trouble Makers or Regular Citizens) J C Lawrence
- Same-Sex Marriage (was: Trouble Makers or Regular Citizens) Ananda Dawnsinger
- Same-Sex Marriage (was: Trouble Makers or Regular Citizens) Jon Lambert
- dealing with foul language Matthew Mihaly
- dealing with foul language Wes Connell
- dealing with foul language Kristen L. Koster
- dealing with foul language Wes Connell
- dealing with foul language Kristen L. Koster
- dealing with foul language Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- dealing with foul language Kristen L. Koster
- dealing with foul language Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- dealing with foul language Kristen L. Koster
- dealing with foul language Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- dealing with foul language Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- dealing with foul language Koster, Raph
- dealing with foul language Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- dealing with foul language Matthew Mihaly
- dealing with foul language Kristen L. Koster
- dealing with foul language Zak Jarvis
- dealing with foul language Darren Henderson
- dealing with foul language Kristen L. Koster
- dealing with foul language AR Schleicher
- dealing with foul language adam@treyarch.com
- Article on Proxes Christopher Allen
- Article on Proxes adam@treyarch.com
- Simulating Ancient Greece WAS: Same-Sex Marriage Zak Jarvis
- Simulating Ancient Greece WAS: Same-Sex Marriage Jon Lambert
- Simulating Ancient Greece WAS: Same-Sex Marriage Matthew Mihaly
- A little essay on economic efficiency Timothy Dang
- Same-Sex Marriage John Hopson
- Same-Sex Marriage Ananda Dawnsinger
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Brian Green
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Zak Jarvis
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul lang uage) Koster, Raph
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Brian Green
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Joe Andrieu
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Matthew Mihaly
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Joe Andrieu
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) adam@treyarch.com
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Historical perspective (was: dealing with foul language) J C Lawrence
- Player controller justice systems David Bennett
- Player controller justice systems Koster, Raph
- Player controller justice systems J C Lawrence
- Player controller justice systems Erik Jarvi
- Player controller justice systems Travis Nixon
- Player controller justice systems Erik Jarvi
- Player controller justice systems Timothy Dang
- Player controller justice systems Draymoor
- Player controller justice systems Erik Jarvi
- Player controller justice systems Phillip Lenhardt
- Player controller justice systems Erik Jarvi
- Family, was characters per account Daniel James
- Family, was characters per account Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Family, was characters per account Kevin Littlejohn
- Family, was characters per account Matthew Mihaly
- Family, was characters per account Phillip Lenhardt
- Family, was characters per account Matthew Mihaly
- Family, was characters per account Shawn Halpenny
- Family, was characters per account Matthew Mihaly
- Family, was characters per account Kevin Littlejohn
- Family, was characters per account Kevin Littlejohn
- Family, was characters per account Jeff Freeman
- Family, was characters per account Raph Koster
- Family, was characters per account Matthew Mihaly
- Family, was characters per account Jeff Freeman
- Family, was characters per account Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Family, was characters per account Matthew Mihaly
- Family, was characters per account Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Family, was characters per account Raph Koster
- Family, was characters per account J C Lawrence
- Family, was characters per account Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Family, was characters per account Raph Koster
- Family, was characters per account Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Gender Restrictions was Same-Sex Marriage Jon Lambert
- Gender Restrictions was Same-Sex Marriage Nathan F Yospe
- Gender Restrictions was Same-Sex Marriage Jon Lambert
- Family, was characters per account J C Lawrence
- Family, was characters per account Phillip Lenhardt
- Family, was characters per account Kevin Scott London
- Family, was characters per account Jeff Freeman
- Family, was characters per account Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gaming sites F. Randall Farmer
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gaming sites maddog@best.com
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gamingsites Zak Jarvis
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gaming sites Ryan Palacio
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popu lar gaming sites Sellers, Michael
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gaming sites maddog@best.com
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gaming sites Wes Connell
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gaming sites Ryan Palacio
- Sony to ban sale of online characters from its popular gaming sites Travis Nixon
- [Meta] other activities Par Winzell
- [Meta] other activities Dominic J. Eidson
- [Meta] other activities Jeff Freeman
- History, background and religion Pileborg Joachim - FMT
- History, background and religion Kevin Scott London
- History, background and religion Matthew Mihaly
- History, background and religion Sanvean
- History, background and religion Sharon Mock
- History, background and religion Richard Ross
- History, background and religion Lovecraft
- DGD Description Christopher Allen
- [Meta] other activities Jeff Freeman
- [Meta] other activities Raph Koster
- [Meta] other activities Todd McKimmey
- [Meta] other activities Matthew Mihaly
- [Meta] other activities Wes Connell
- Personal Interest vs. Marketing Decision WAS dealing with foul language Zak Jarvis
- Threads on Meta that should be on MUD-Dev J C Lawrence
- [Meta] Threads on Meta that should be on MUD-Dev J C Lawrence
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran S. Patrick Gallaty
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran John Bertoglio
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran S. Patrick Gallaty
- Family, was characters per account Chris Lloyd
- [LONG] A slightly different perspective on Real money in Virtual worlds. Zak Jarvis
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Frank Crowell
- banning the sale of items Geoffrey A. MacDougall
- banning the sale of items Raph Koster
> -----Original Message-----
> From: mud-dev-admin@kanga.nu [mailto:mud-dev-admin@kanga.nu]On Behalf Of
> Geoffrey A. MacDougall
> Sent: Tuesday, April 11, 2000 11:31 PM
> To: 'mud-dev@kanga.nu'
> Subject: RE: [MUD-Dev] banning the sale of items
>
> From what I know of you MUD, Matt, you are operating at a scale
> where it is
> financially feasible for you to investigate and patch any errors that may
> have resulted in players losing virtual goods for which they paid RL
> currency. I would hesitate to assume that the same model would be
> functionable at a larger scale.
Well, if it isn't now, it probably will be at some point, It's a braindead
obvious business move that has been proven to work at smaller scales. Sega
was going to try it in a big way with LEDOs a while back, and others have
taken whacks at it. The profits that eBay makes from these sales is enticing
enough to any game developer... :)
> I think that Raph has the best take on the matter - don't condone or
rebut,
> but simply take it as a compliment that your creation has such tremendous
> value to a wide variety of people.
Well, thanks for endorsing my viewpoint. :) But there's more to my thoughts
on it than that...
Ryan's thesis can be boiled down to:
- the more people value something, the more they are likely to bend or break
rules in order to get it
- people value real life cash more than they value in-game rules
By this logic, of course, one can quickly conclude that people will value
the cash from eBay auctions more than they value the TOS for EQ. :) The
hardly-slowed pace of auctions on eBay attests to this. It also suggests
that Crockford is correct when he states that they are fighting the
inevitable.
Verant's approach is to attempt to remove the things that are valued more
than in-game rules, thus making the in-game rules paramount. This is, IMHO,
impossible, but it may be feasible to do it to the point where it ceases
being much of an admin issue.
However, the admin issues also relate to the nature of what goods are being
sold. This issue came up at the GDC panel I did with Brad McQuaid & Toby
Ragaini of AC as well as others (I mention those two in particular because
we had contrasting views).
The admin issues can be identified pretty readily:
A- does this result in increased admin calls, thereby reducing profit?
B- does this result in shortened gameplay, thus reducing dollars extracted
from the customer?
On (A), the question to answer is whether cons and misrepresentation of
goods are 1) possible, 2) generating many admin complaints.
Toby and Brad would give, I suspect, affirmative answers to A1, and to a
lesser degree, A2 (lesser because from any given transaction, a subset
results in dissatisfaction, and a subset thereof results in an admin call).
For UO, I would suspect that the answer to A1 is "not for the biggest ticket
item" and therefore the answer to A2 is "not much, really."
This is because of the goods sold. So let's break those down. First off,
often what are sold are accounts. But the question is really, what is it
that people wish to obtain with said accounts? The answer varies per game.
- high level characters
- specific portable items and equipment, including "rare" items
- real estate, comprising housing or other immovable but formal forms of
territorial ownership
- real estate, comprising spawn points, access to zones, or other immovable
but informal forms of territorial ownership
When purchasing an account for one or more of the above, there are elements
which are easily falsified to a buyer, and elements that are not.
Specifically, it is easier to commit fraud with portable items like
characters or items, and harder to do with real estate. Similarly, it is
harder to do with some sorts of "rares" and easier to do with others:
there's little point in falsifying a +3 sword because they are common, lots
of point in falsifying something that most people cannot identify, and
little point in falsifying items that people can identify visually but are
still rare.
To break down some specific examples from the three games:
- characters in EQ are moderately easy to falsify, because they are heavily
equipment dependent, and you can hand that off before completing the
transaction.
- full spellbooks in UO are easy to falsify because you can't open them to
check them before buying from a vendor.
- "Rares" like necromantic reagents in UO are hard to falsify because anyone
can recognize them at a glace.
- Houses in UO are hard to falsify because they're, well, large objects
sitting there that you can check on anytime whether the seller is online or
not.
- Equipment in EQ or UO is easier to falsify, but some swords are hard and
some are easy because of their availability (hard to run effective swindles
selling common items--cons depend on selling what looks like a rare
opportunity).
- Spawn points in UO are harder to control than in EQ or AC (I'd rank it
overall as EQ, AC, UO, in terms of easiest to hardest--though there are
places like the Lich Lord room in UO where it is just as easy to camp as in
EQ). Therefore they are harder to sell. There aren't many data points on
sales of spawn points yet, though.
Thus we can see that there are some types of item sales that are likely to
result in admin calls and other types which are not. Empirically, a lot of
admin calls resulted from vendors swindling people out of full spellbooks. A
lot less for people selling houses on eBay.
Next comes the question of whether these items reduce profit in terms of
reducing the game's longevity--or whether they actually enhance it.
- Characters obviously do. You shortcut the mountains to climb and the
oceans to swim. It's like a cheat code.
- Equipment which serves to enhance the character also does.
- Equipment gathered for "collectible" purposes, eg the rares market in UO,
actually *increases* account longevity. It has become an embedded elder
game. (one, I might add, with huge database costs. ;)
- Houses also extend account longevity, rather than shortening it. Yes,
houses are a "goal" to reach, but they also serve to tie the player to the
game. Players with houses are far less likely to leave the game.
- Spawn point access sales are purely detrimental to account longevity for
many reasons.
From this we can conclude that it's possible that the benefits of selling
longevity-enhancing elements within the game may actually outweigh the cost
of admin calls as a result of swindles--particularly if what is sold is hard
to swindle with. You can reduce the amount of admin calls (thus making these
elements even more profitable) by increasing the levels of security on the
trades that are occuring. This means more to your bottom line, even if you
do not take the step of charging for these goods yourself.
As you might guess, Brad and Toby said that eBay auctioning was bad. And I
said that it was mostly good. And the reasons why are because of what gets
sold on the respective games. So I think Ryan's thesis is absolutely
correct--for EverQuest.
And, btw, I also think this shows that Daniel, Janus, and Steve on the
Realm/MiddleEarth teams had the right idea: just give every player a house
from the get go. :)
-Raph - banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Jeff Freeman
- banning the sale of items Raph Koster
- banning the sale of items Jeff Freeman
- banning the sale of items Ryan Palacio
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Ryan Palacio
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Ryan Palacio
- banning the sale of items Tess Lowe
- banning the sale of items Ryan Palacio
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- banning the sale of items Ryan Palacio
- banning the sale of items Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Raph Koster
- banning the sale of items Ryan Palacio
- banning the sale of items Raph Koster
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Schubert, Damion
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Ananda Dawnsinger
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Wes Connell
- banning the sale of items Par Winzell
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Par Winzell
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Zak Jarvis
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Zak Jarvis
- banning the sale of items J. Coleman
- banning the sale of items Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- banning the sale of items Tess Lowe
- banning the sale of items Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- banning the sale of items Christopher Allen
- banning the sale of items Ryan Palacio
- banning the sale of items Kristen L. Koster
- banning the sale of items Christopher Allen
- banning the sale of items Par Winzell
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items J C Lawrence
- banning the sale of items Par Winzell
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items adam@treyarch.com
- banning the sale of items Kevin Littlejohn
- banning the sale of items Raph Koster
- banning the sale of items Raph Koster
- banning the sale of items Matthew Mihaly
- banning the sale of items Kian Wilcox
- banning the sale of items Timothy Dang
- Institutionalizing human behavior (was banning the sale of items) Sellers, Michael
- Institutionalizing human behavior (was banning the sale of items) Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran Brian Green
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran John Bertoglio
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran Wes Connell
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran J C Lawrence
- Sony to ban sale ... point of view of an eq veteran Jeff Freeman
- [Meta] Of general interest maybe Jeff Freeman
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Raph Koster
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Matthew Mihaly
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Jeff Freeman
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Jeff Freeman
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Geoffrey Z.
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Schubert, Damion
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) J C Lawrence
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Nathan F Yospe
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) F. Randall Farmer
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Travis Casey
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Lee Sheldon
- Spawning and quests (was Sony ban) Wes Connell
- DDoS Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- /. Article about EQ sales ban Nathan F Yospe
- /. Article about EQ sales ban Raph Koster
- MudDev FAQ part 2 Marian Griffith
- MudDev FAQ part 2 Ananda Dawnsinger
- MudDev FAQ part 2 Raph Koster
- MudDev FAQ part 2 Dr Richard A. Bartle
- Family, was characters per account Raph Koster
- Institutionalizing human behavior (was banning the sale of items) Xavier Plagnal
- meets Matthew Mihaly
- Quoting. J C Lawrence
- Amy Jo Kim's "Community Building on the Web" Raph Koster
- Amy Jo Kim's "Community Building on the Web" Richard Woolcock
- Amy Jo Kim's "Community Building on the Web" F. Randall Farmer
- Amy Jo Kim's "Community Building on the Web" Sellers, Michael
- Institutionalizing human behavior Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Christopher Allen
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Erik Jarvi
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Geoffrey A. MacDougall
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars John Bertoglio
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Jon Lambert
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Geoffrey A. MacDougall
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Geoffrey A. MacDougall
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Jon Lambert
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Jeff Freeman
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Travis Casey
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Jeff Freeman
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Geoffrey A. MacDougall
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Eli Stevens
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Travis Casey
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Travis S. Casey
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Jeff Freeman
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Geoffrey A. MacDougall
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Travis S. Casey
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Par Winzell
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Christopher Allen
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Par Winzell
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Phillip Lenhardt
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Raph Koster
- Spawning and quests Spin
- Spawning and quests Chris Lloyd
- Spawning and quests adam@treyarch.com
- (no subject) J C Lawrence
- E3 and potential meet? Ryan Palacio
- E3 and potential meet? J C Lawrence
- Scott Guzman on RGM.Admin J C Lawrence
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Raph Koster
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Ananda Dawnsinger
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Erik Jarvi
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Ryan Palacio
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Erik Jarvi
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Dmitri Zagidulin
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Phillip Lenhardt
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Raph Koster
- Quote from a Simutronics developer Ananda Dawnsinger
- Quests - allocative efficiency Lovecraft
- Common Law [was: Declaration of the Rights of Avatars] Christopher Allen
- Common Law [was: Declaration of the Rights of Avatars] Christopher Allen
- AI, Bots, Scripting. Veygoth
- AI, Bots, Scripting. David Bennett
- Quests Raph Koster
- Alignment Richard Ross
- ADMIN: Digest size J C Lawrence
- Circular Alignment [was: Alignment] Christopher Allen
- Value of Characters [was: Quote from a Simutronics developer] Christopher Allen
- MUD-Dev request rejected Schubert, Damion
- MUD-Dev request rejected John Szeder
- Skotos Proximity System - a Technical Summary (LONG) Christopher Allen
- Skotos Proximity System - a Technical Summary (LONG) Erik Jarvi
- Skotos Proximity System - a Technical Summary (LONG) Christopher Allen
- Skotos Proximity System - a Technical Summary (LONG) Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- The scalability of paying for in-game things Matthew Mihaly
- The scalability of paying for in-game things Brian Green
- The scalability of paying for in-game things Matthew Mihaly
- The scalability of paying for in-game things Brian Green
- The scalability of paying for in-game things Par Winzell
- ALife? was [Personal Interest vs. Marketing Decision WAS RE:...] Greg Underwood
- incremental revenue discussion Matthew Mihaly
- new list Kevin Littlejohn
- Justifying twinking Raph Koster
- Justifying twinking adam@treyarch.com
- Justifying twinking Raph Koster
- Justifying twinking adam@treyarch.com
- Justifying twinking Ryan Palacio
- Justifying twinking F. Randall Farmer
- Justifying twinking Ryan Palacio
- Justifying twinking Raph Koster
- Justifying twinking Raph Koster
- Justifying twinking Todd McKimmey
- Justifying twinking Hess, Ian W {Ian}
- Justifying twinking Jeff Freeman
- Justifying twinking Schubert, Damion
- Justifying twinking Lee Sheldon
- Justifying twinking adam@treyarch.com
- Justifying twinking Lee Sheldon
- Justifying twinking Travis S. Casey
- Justifying twinking John Bertoglio
- Justifying twinking Travis Nixon
- Justifying twinking Lee Sheldon
- Justifying twinking Travis S. Casey
- Justifying twinking Caliban Tiresias Darklock
- Justifying twinking Christopher Allen
- Justifying twinking J C Lawrence
- Justifying twinking adam@treyarch.com
- Justifying twinking Christopher Allen
- Justifying twinking Travis Casey
- Justifying twinking Lee Sheldon
- Justifying twinking Sellers, Michael
- Justifying twinking Mud Imp
- Justifying twinking Brian Green
- Justifying twinking John Bertoglio
- Justifying twinking Ananda Dawnsinger
- Justifying twinking Christopher Allen
- Justifying twinking Travis Casey
- Justifying twinking Timothy Dang
- Justifying twinking jolson@micron.net
- Justifying twinking Travis Nixon
- Justifying twinking John Bertoglio
- Justifying twinking jolson@micron.net
- Justifying twinking Raph Koster
- Justifying twinking Christopher Allen
- Justifying twinking Schubert, Damion
- Justifying twinking adam@treyarch.com
- Justifying twinking Christopher Allen
- Justifying twinking adam@treyarch.com
- Justifying twinking Geoffrey Z.
- Justifying twinking Justin Lockshaw
- Justifying twinking Raph Koster
- Justifying twinking S. Patrick Gallaty
- Justifying twinking Frank Crowell
- Justifying twinking Lee Sheldon
- Justifying twinking Lee Sheldon
- Game Law Example (fwd) J C Lawrence
- Game Law Example (fwd) Travis S. Casey
- Fun and Learning in games Draymoor
- Fun and Learning in games Schubert, Damion
- Fun and Learning in games adam@treyarch.com
- Re PRIVATE Justifying twinking Kristen L. Koster
- Re PRIVATE Justifying twinking Josh Olson
- Database back ends dwacks@saleslogix.com
- Database back ends Greg Underwood
- Database back ends Quiet
- Database back ends Kevin Littlejohn
- defeating twinking through game mechanics S. Patrick Gallaty
- defeating twinking through game mechanics jolson@micron.net
- defeating twinking through game mechanics adam@treyarch.com
- defeating twinking through game mechanics S. Patrick Gallaty
- defeating twinking through game mechanics Erik Jarvi
- defeating twinking through game mechanics Travis S. Casey
- defeating twinking through game mechanics Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- defeating twinking through game mechanics Travis Casey
- defeating twinking through game mechanics Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- defeating twinking through game mechanics J C Lawrence
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Timothy Dang
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" F. Randall Farmer
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Christopher Allen
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Raph Koster
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Timothy Dang
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Timothy Dang
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Brian Green
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" adam@treyarch.com
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Timothy Dang
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Ananda Dawnsinger
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Charles Hughes
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Raph Koster
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Sellers, Michael
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Raph Koster
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Charles Hughes
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Caliban Tiresias Darklock
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" adam@treyarch.com
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" stoddart@slip.net
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Eli Stevens
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" Raph Koster
- Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO" PLAGNAL XAVIER
- Massive Connections Christopher Kohnert
- Massive Connections Kevin Scott London
- Massive Connections Christopher Kohnert
- MUD-Dev request rejected Jeff Freeman
- interesting article on world size and finance Fred Clift
- interesting article on world size and finance J C Lawrence
- interesting article on world size and finance John Bertoglio
- [Mud-Dev]: Sushi Mud Todd McKimmey
- [Mud-Dev]: Sushi Mud guru@thebay.plus.com
- LA Times article: Virtual Loot for Real Cash Ryan Palacio
- LA Times article: Virtual Loot for Real Cash J C Lawrence
- Alignment (very long) Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Alignment (very long) Christopher Allen
- Alignment (very long) Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Alignment (very long) Kevin Littlejohn
- Alignment (very long) Travis Casey
- Alignment (very long) Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Character persistance, was Family, was characters per account JC
- Character persistance, was Family, was characters per account Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) J C Lawrence
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) Charles
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) J C Lawrence
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) Caliban Tiresias Darklock
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) Chris Jacobson
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) Caliban Tiresias Darklock
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) Richard Ross
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) Lee Sheldon
- shrink wrapped mud development kit (fwd) Matt Chatterley
- BioWare to demonstrate Neverwinter Nights at E3 F. Randall Farmer
- BioWare to demonstrate Neverwinter Nights at E3 Jeff Freeman
- BioWare to demonstrate Neverwinter Nights at E3 Travis Casey
- ColdStore. Belated response from a developer. colin@field.medicine.adelaide.edu.au
- ColdStore. Belated response from a developer. Miroslav Silovic
- ColdStore. Belated response from a developer. Jay Carlson
- ColdStore. Belated response from a developer. colin@field.medicine.adelaide.edu.au
- [Meta] Ex-Origin Employees to new Verant studio Eli Stevens
- Game Spec Jman77777@aol.com
- From banning the sale of items to virtual slavery... Stéphane Garin
- Search engine and thread managing Stéphane Garin
- Search engine and thread managing J C Lawrence
- LED0 Frank Crowell
- Re[4]: defeating twinking through game mechanics Travis Casey
- MUME poll results (fwd) J C Lawrence
- MUME poll results (fwd) Christopher Allen
- MUME poll results (fwd) Raph Koster
- MUME poll results (fwd) Charles Hughes
- MUME poll results (fwd) Eric Olsen
- MUME poll results (fwd) Charles Hughes
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods J C Lawrence
- selling Godhoods Chris Jacobson
- selling Godhoods Ananda Dawnsinger
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods Ananda Dawnsinger
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods Ananda Dawnsinger
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods Phillip Lenhardt
- selling Godhoods Ananda Dawnsinger
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods Darren Henderson
- selling Godhoods J C Lawrence
- selling Godhoods Raph Koster
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods Darren Henderson
- selling Godhoods Tess Lowe
- selling Godhoods Ananda Dawnsinger
- selling Godhoods Richard Woolcock
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods Richard Woolcock
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods J C Lawrence
- selling Godhoods Tess Lowe
- selling Godhoods Richard Woolcock
- Selling Godhoods!?! Larvenz
- selling Godhoods Par Winzell
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- Selling Godhoods!?! Par Winzell
- Selling Godhoods!?! Hans-Henrik Staerfeldt
- selling Godhoods Jeff Freeman
- Selling Godhoods!?! Mud Imp
- Selling Godhoods!?! J C Lawrence
- Selling Godhoods!?! Kevin Scott London
- Selling Godhoods!?! Christopher Kohnert
- Selling Godhoods!?! Kevin Scott London
- Selling Godhoods!?! Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- selling Godhoods J C Lawrence
- selling Godhoods Raph Koster
- selling Godhoods Ananda Dawnsinger
- selling Godhoods Raph Koster
- selling Godhoods Laurent Bossavit
- selling Godhoods lapsos
- selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- selling Godhoods Par Winzell
- moving advancement away from experience Eli Stevens
- moving advancement away from experience Travis Casey
- moving advancement away from experience Caliban Tiresias Darklock
- moving advancement away from experience Lee Sheldon
- E3 and exhibit/session passes (follow-ups to Meta) Sellers, Michael
- attracting players Mud Imp
- attracting players Richard Woolcock
- attracting players Chris Lloyd
- Attracting players Koster, Raph
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Chris Lloyd
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Christopher Allen
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Schubert, Damion
- Self-Sufficient Worlds John Bertoglio
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Quzah
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Phillip Lenhardt
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Mordengaard
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Chris Turner
- Self-Sufficient Worlds lapsos
- Self-Sufficient Worlds F. Randall Farmer
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Chad Arnold
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Sellers, Michael
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Chris Lloyd
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Raph Koster
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Raph Koster
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Raph Koster
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Raph Koster
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds J C Lawrence
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Matthew Mihaly
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Sellers, Michael
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Powell, Warren
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Lee Sheldon
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Angela Ferraiolo
- Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- Self-Sufficient Worlds J C Lawrence
- Addressing newbies (was: attracting players) Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- Addressing newbies (was: attracting players) Jerry Hill
- Addressing newbies (was: attracting players) adam@treyarch.com
- Addressing newbies (was: attracting players) adam@treyarch.com
- reaction to selling godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- reaction to selling godhoods Kevin Scott London
- Crafts Systems (was:Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO") Ananda Dawnsinger
- Crafts Systems (was:Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO") Raph Koster
- Crafts Systems (was:Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO") Charles Hughes
- Crafts Systems (was:Simpson's "In-Game Economics of UO") Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- datagrams Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- a article on ai -- ANTS -- (fwd) J C Lawrence
- FW: selling Godhoods John Bertoglio
- FW: selling Godhoods Matthew Mihaly
- Skotos Bulk System - a Technical Summary (LONG) Christopher Allen
- "The client is in the hands of the enemy" Schubert, Damion
- "The client is in the hands of the enemy" Zak Jarvis
- "The client is in the hands of the enemy" Kevin Littlejohn
- Procedural Storytelling WAS Self-Sufficient Worlds Zak Jarvis
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Zak Jarvis
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling J C Lawrence
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Raph Koster
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling rob@cs.nwu.edu
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Travis Nixon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Hess, Ian W {Ian}
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling J C Lawrence
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Travis Nixon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Raph Koster
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Marian Griffith
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Ola Fosheim Grøstad
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Zak Jarvis
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Travis Nixon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Paul Schwanz - Enterprise Services
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Travis Nixon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brian Green
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Travis Nixon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Sam Axon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Travis Nixon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brian Green
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Kevin Littlejohn
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Angela Ferraiolo
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Erik Jarvi
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Nathan F Yospe
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Erik Jarvi
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Nathan F Yospe
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Raph Koster
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Batir
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Raph Koster
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Kristen L. Koster
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Batir
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Raph Koster
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Charles Hughes
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Erik Jarvi
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Matthew Mihaly
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Lee Sheldon
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Matthew Mihaly
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Joe Andrieu
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Rawlings@aol.com
- A footnote to Procedural Storytelling Brandon J. Rickman