October 2000
- Interactive Fiction Competition 2000 Aaron Mitchell
- trade skill idea msew
- trade skill idea Josh Olson
- trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea Josh Olson
- trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea Matthew Mihaly
- trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea Josh Olson
Son of a...
I had a lengthy reply typed up when my computer lost power. Pathetic
reconstruction of the original follows below:
----- Original Message -----
From: "Koster, Raph" <rkoster@verant.com>
> > But notice that in none of the games you mentioned does anyone spend
their
> > days doing one thing, ie making bread.
>
> Now you're just talking about the granularity of the simulation at any
given
> point. Is it conceivable that you might spend all day doing just one
thing?
> Sure, if the simulation level of that one thing is complex enough that in
> itself it provides sufficient detail and choices to keep you interested.
For
> example, it's easy to see how you could build SimAnt into The Sims, and
> SimsVille out of lots of cases of the Sims, and SimCity out of lots of
cases
> of SimsVille, and SimEarth out of lots of cases of SimCity. (In fact, when
> SimEarth came out, there was a key you could press that responded with
"This
> key will eventually place your SimCity into your SimEarth, in a future
> product.").
It's easy to see how you could do that, but I'm baffled at why you would
want to. Each of the Sim games has a discrete and appropriate scale that
works well for that game. Building enough SimCities to populate an entire
SimEarth would drown out the latter with endless repetitions of the former.
Before long you'd be praying for a Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri-style
"governor" button that would build the cities for you. Granularity may be
arbitrary, but scope is quite significant.
> If making bread was the point of the game, and there were dozens of
grains,
> many sorts of ovens, many possible bread shapes, and lots of
> variables--sure, what the heck. It could get especially challenging if
there
> were managing multiple ovens and bakeries at once. Not that I am
suggesting
> making this game--I am just saying that if you break down the games here,
> and examine them topologically (what is the SHAPE of the gameplay), you'll
> find extreme similarities.
This is a fine example of overextending scope. Do you suppose that the
manager of a chain of bakeries is the same person who grinds grain, mixes
dough, packages loaves, etc. etc. in each bakery? Almost certainly not -
there isn't enough time in the day to run the minute-to-minute operations of
each store as well as manage the corporate aspects of the entire chain.
You can either have a game about baking bread, or you can have a game about
managing bakeries - you can't have it both ways and maintain an interesting
level of complexity in both aspects. The more detailed the simulation, the
tighter your scope must be. Corollary: the broader your scope, the more
details must be glossed over.
> But I'd argue that even this is icing on the cake. The REAL attractant to
> RCT or Sims is the stuff that has fairly little impact on gameplay.
Painting
> wall colors and making new skins for your Sims, now THAT was fun--and it's
> what the fan community is out there going nuts for.
I'd argue that the painting and skinning would not be so attractive if the
underlying game didn't have a lot of merit in the first place. If I just
wanted to play SimDressup, I'd buy a Barbie game.
> I'll say it again: I believe that a game about doing nothing more than
> interior decorating has a bigger potential audience than a game about
going
> on a grand adventure and saving the day.
Perhaps, but I don't think it would capture interest for as long. Marking
your environment and displaying your originality is much more appealing an
an already-interesting context.
-Josh Olson - trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea Matthew Mihaly
- trade skill idea msew
- trade skill idea Travis Casey
- trade skill idea Josh Olson
- trade skill idea Zak Jarvis
- trade skill idea Josh Olson
- trade skill idea John Buehler
- trade skill idea Dave Rickey
- trade skill idea Zak Jarvis
- trade skill idea Josh Olson
- trade skill idea Mordengaard
- trade skill idea Richard Tew
- trade skill idea Val Trullinger
- trade skill idea Phillip Lenhardt
- trade skill idea John Buehler
- trade skill idea Matthew Mihaly
- trade skill idea msew
- trade skill idea Wes Connell
- trade skill idea Matthew Mihaly
- trade skill idea Brad Wyble
- trade skill idea Vincent Archer
- trade skill idea Jeff Freeman
- trade skill idea Corey Crawford
- trade skill idea Yves K
- trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea Tamzen Cannoy
- trade skill idea Robert Zubek
- trade skill idea Patrick Dughi
- trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea Matthew Mihaly
- trade skill idea Brian 'Psychochild' Green
- trade skill idea msew
- trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea Matthew Mihaly
- trade skill idea Josh Olson
- trade skill idea Matthew Mihaly
- trade skill idea Koster, Raph
- trade skill idea msew
- trade skill idea Batir
- trade skill idea Arabis2000@aol.com
- Open Source 3D Interactive World Server Ian Macintosh
- Reactive keyboard J C Lawrence
- MUD-Dev digest, Vol 1 #243 - 14 msgs Dr. Cat
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Ananda Dawnsinger
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Madman Across the Water
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? sverre@munthe.net
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Jeff Freeman
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Matthew Mihaly
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Marc Bowden
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Ananda Dawnsinger
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Zak Jarvis
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Madman Across the Water
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Vincent Archer
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Dave Rickey
- Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Ananda Dawnsinger
- Mud / Web Integeration Lee Hulbert
- Mud / Web Integeration Wes Connell
- Mud / Web Integeration Bruce
- Mud / Web Integeration Bruce
- Mud / Web Integeration KevinL
- Mud / Web Integeration msew
- Mud / Web Integeration msew
- Mud / Web Integeration Richard Tew
- Mud / Web Integeration Nathan F. Yospe
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars sverre@munthe.net
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Matthew Mihaly
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Justin Rogers
- Declaration of the Rights of Avatars Andy
- OT: Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Brian 'Psychochild' Green
- OT: Banning Players for Off-Site Activities? Ananda Dawnsinger
- Grandmaster Nuclear Safety Technicion or Grandmaster Warrior ( was John Szeder
- Alternate Means of EQUAL Enjoyment (formerly trade skill idea) Geoffrey MacDougall
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Richard Tew
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Zak Jarvis
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Inq Admin
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Richard Tew
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Matthew Mihaly
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Koster, Raph
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Richard Tew
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Matthew Mihaly
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Richard Tew
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Inq Admin
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain William McCarroll
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Matthew Mihaly
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Mordengaard
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Justin Rogers
- Realistic travel times/virtual terrain Matthew Mihaly
- Grandmaster Nuclear Safety Technicion or Grandmaster Willowreed@aol.com
- [world-create] Progressive Aristocracy (fwd) J C Lawrence
- [world-create] Progressive Aristocracy (fwd) Matthew Mihaly
- VRML Richard Tew
- Admin: System outage J C Lawrence
- absolute vs. relative coords KevinL
- absolute vs. relative coords Inq Admin
- absolute vs. relative coords Nathan F. Yospe
- ADMIN: More troubles I'm afraid, and the details of the recovery. J C Lawrence
- integrated character webpages ala Black and White creature pages msew
- integrated character webpages ala Black and White creature pages msew
- Admin: Kang.Nu troubles J C Lawrence
- Admin: Kanga.Nu troubles... J C Lawrence
- travel times (commercial/graphical vs grassroots/text) Fredfish {E. Harper}
- travel times (commercial/graphical vs grassroots/text) the_logos@www.achaea.com
- Admin: We're back in business J C Lawrence
- Triangular Damage Infliction System Ben
- Triangular Damage Infliction System Ben Chambers
- Triangular Damage Infliction System Travis Casey
- Fwd: absolute vs. relative coords Nathan F.Yospe
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Christopher Allen
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Chris Lloyd
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? tanis@mediacom.it
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Christopher Allen
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Federico Di Gregorio
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Christopher Allen
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Frank Crowell
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Frank Crowell
- Opinions (even harsh) on Castle Marrach by Skotos? Christopher Allen